The One Question to Never Answer at Traffic Stops

If a motorist is pulled over for an alleged traffic violation, they need to understand their basic rights. Law enforcement will often try to circumvent restrictive laws to reach the end result they are looking for. In some cases, a police officer may even bully or manipulate the motorist to such a degree that they confess to a crime they may not have committed. This could result in that person needing the services of a criminal defense lawyer in Tampa.

The Traffic Stop Question

When it comes to traffic stops, it’s best to let the police officer do most of the talking; however, sometimes the first words out of the police officer’s mouth can lead to the incriminating response they are hoping for. As most of us have experienced, the officer approaches your window and asks if you know why they “stopped you.” Answering this question alone may seal your fate.

The Tough Self-Evaluation

Many honest, law-abiding motorists with a guilty conscience will over analyze their current predicament. They will become overly critical of their driving skills or consider how they potentially violated the law. In some cases, the police officer’s aggressive tone of voice will intimidate the motorist into responding to the question because they want to satisfy the officer and potentially alleviate the escalating situation. Unfortunately, in many cases, this only creates more problems for the motorist.

Incriminating Yourself

Whether it’s admitting to changing lanes without a blinker, slightly going over the speed limit, not coming to a full stop, or another minor traffic offense, the end result is that the motorist has just implicated themselves to a traffic violation. On a grander scale, this could mean that the motorist agrees to an unlawful search of their vehicle or is arrested for an incident completely unrelated to the reason why they were pulled over in the first place.

How the Officer Manipulated the Situation

In many cases, the officer may not have been aware that any infraction had actually transpired when they pulled over the vehicle and was simply fishing for the motorists to voluntarily divulge any incriminating evidence to the officer. Although it’s important to be honest, respectful, and cooperative with the police officer, it’s also important to not give the officer any authority beyond their jurisdiction. As the old saying goes, “give an inch and they’ll take a mile.”

For a free consultation with an experienced criminal defense attorney in Tampa, please contact The Rickman Law Firm today.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for general educational information only. This information does not constitute legal advice, is not intended to constitute legal advice, nor should it be relied upon as legal advice for your specific factual pattern or situation.

Case Results

Possession of Marijuana Charge-Dismissed

The Defendant was stopped by law enforcement. After claiming to smell marijuana, the Defendant was handcuffed and searched. After marijuana was found the Defendant was charged with possession. The Defense was able to successfully get
Show More


The Client was charged with Driving Under the Influence. Attorney Anthony Rickman was able to get the DUI charge reduced to Reckless Driving.
Show More

Felony Criminal Mischief Charges Dropped

Our Client was accused of kicking the alleged victim’s Ferrari and causing $3,000.00 in damage during an argument. The Defense had the felony charge reduced to a misdemeanor and our Client received time served with
Show More